The Advice of a Jew


(An EXTRACT from a discourse by Hadhrat Qaari Muhammad Tayyib, the former Principal of Daarul Uloom Deoband)

“I remember a very interesting incident. Maulana Salim Sahib (Rahimahullah) was living in Makkah Mukarramah. During the Zionist Revolution the Jews had taken control of some areas of Egypt and of Masjid al Aqsa as well. He narrated an incident of a person that came from Egypt when Gaza was taken over by the Jews.

The Muslims fled from there to Egypt to save their lives and honour. A poor old scholar also left with his wife. They had no conveyance, so they travelled on foot, struggling for 30 to 40 kilometres to Al Arīsh. From there, the border of Egypt was closed. The Jews then captured him.

From the opposite side, a Jeep of one of the Jewish commanders was coming. The scholar was holding the hands of his children. The commander had took pity on him due to his old age.

He stopped his Jeep and asked, “Who are you?” He said his name. “Where do you want to go?” He replied, “Cairo.” “Why?” “There is unrest here.” The commander said, “Have you no transport?” The old scholar replied, “No, I do not have transport. There was a revolution and the Jews took control.” The Jewish commander said, “I pity your old age. Sit in my car; I shall take you to the border. Where will you take your wife and weak children? It is forty miles from here.”

At first, the old scholar was apprehensive, fearing that this person had ill designs for him and his family. The commander then assured him of safety. “Please be convinced, I shall take you there.” He took the family to an Egyptian camp which the Jews had taken control of.

The commander took him to a tent, left him there saying, “Rest for a while. Rest, I shall bring food. You eat, and then I shall take you.”

He made the old man sit on a sofa, while the commander sat on the ground. The commander said, “You should be aware of Umar (radhiyallahu anhu)?” The old man said, “What! He is a Sahabi and a great Khalifah of Nabi (sallallahu alayhi wasallam).” The commander said, “Can you mention some of his qualities?” The old man replied, “Yes.” He then began to mention the virtues, status, and perfection of Sayyidunā Umar (radhiyallahu anhu).

After attentively listening, the Jewish commander said, “Are these the qualities of Umar (radhiyallahu anhu)?” He said, “Yes.” The commander said, “When these qualities were in the Muslims, then we, the Jews, were in subjugation at their feet. What is your condition today? The room that I have seated you in, it is the room of an Egyptian Lieutenant. Yesterday, twenty five soldiers were under him. This is his tent. Bottles of liquor are lined in it. There are couches here. Lawful women (wives) and unlawful women (prostitutes) were with him. Yet he came to fight the Jews. So why should the Jews not overpower and defeat him? When the qualities of Umar (radhiyallahu anhu) were present, the Jews were beneath your feet. Why are you grieving?”

The scholar was now silent. What answer should he give? It is reality. The commander said: “I only wanted to show you this (i.e.. the immoral condition of the Muslim army). Now come, I shall take you.” He took the scholar in his Jeep and left him at the border of Cairo. The scholar thanked him. The commander said, “We do not oppose your religion, we oppose you people. You do not follow your religion or our religion. You indulge in liquor, immorality and amusement, so why should we not fight you? Why should we not assert control over you?”

One thought on “The Advice of a Jew

  1. Taalib ul Ilm

    Assalamu Alaykum
    Today even our supposedly Deeni Concious Ulul Amr (clergy, imams, community leaders, elders and ladies) sit in Masjid Halls and dine on tables and chairs under cover of ‘walimah.’
    When this is the state of our Masajids, Madaris, Khaanqahs, Tableegh Jamaat, Islamic Schools and Academies, what hope is there of the Muslim Ummah preparing anybody who will be able to withstand the onslaught of kufr and baatil?
    Nevertheless, there will insha’Allah always remain a pious Servants of Deen (like our Venerable Hadhrat Mufti Saheb – Allah Ta’ala maintain his shadow over this Ummah).
    Ameerul Mumineen ‘Umar (radhiyallaahu ‘anhu) narrated,
    فإن الحق قديم لا يبطل الحق شيء
    “Haqque (Truth) is Timeless (Haqque is independent of our existence, it existed from before & will exist in the future) & nothing can cancel out Haqque (Truth).”


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *